Simulation results of some sample projects

ZDT 3.5

A 3.5-way speaker created by John "Zaph" Krutke. Uses Dayton drivers. Clean design and excellent simulation results.
All about the ZDT 3.5

Screenshot of ZDT 3.5

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

3W-Classic

A classic 3-way speaker designed by Troels Gravesen. Uses Seas drivers. Clean design and excellent simulation results.
All about the 3W-Classic

Screenshot of 3W-Classic

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

Prima

A 2-way speaker proposed by Kro. Scan-Speak drivers from the discovery series and a simple crossover yield a very nice result.
All about the Prima

Screenshot of Prima

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

ER18DXT

A 2-way speaker created by Mark K using a first order crossover. The simulation is close to the published measurements.
All about the ER18DXT

Screenshot of ER18DXT

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

Veepers Monitor

A 2-way speaker proposed by Louis Corragio. Uses Peerless and Vifa drivers. The simulation is close to the published ground plane measurements.
All about the Veepers Monitor

Screenshot of Veepers

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

Starling

A 2-way speaker created by Michael Chua. Uses Seas drivers. The crossover is somewhat unconventional, but the simulation basically agrees with the published measurements.
All about the Starling

Screenshot of Starling

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

Overnight Sensations

A popular mini speaker designed by Paul Carmody. Uses a HiVi woofer and a Dayton tweeter (first version). The simulation shows a peak at 2 kHz, which does not appear in the published measurements.
All about the Overnight Sensations

Screenshot

Crossover
Driver Voltages
Maximum SPL
Step Response

Comments

MZ SpeakerDesigner simulates complete passive loudspeakers and predicts all major data used in speaker design. As this is done in the abstract, no measurements are required to get a simulation. Actually I do not have a single speaker shown above...

The only exception is the driver database. A driver defined only by its Thiele-Small parameters will not give accurate results. A reference measurement is required to adjust the impedance and spl simulation of the driver. Fortunately and unlike other programs, MZ SpeakerDesigner does not need phase data from measurements. Therefore you can use any impedance or spl graph you find in datasheets, magazins or the internet for that purpose, provided the measurement conditions are known and the data is not too much faked, as few manufacturers still do. Faster and easier is to import an electronic data file. Great compliment to Wavecor for providing this service!

The system database of the first version of MZ SpeakerDesigner will be small but reliable. I only add drivers to the system database, if I have at least three independent sources, which are more or less in accordance. The Thiele-Small parameters may differ slightly from manufacturers data.

The accuracy of the simulation stands and falls with the driver data used. If you compare independent measurements of the same driver, you will often find significant differences. For that reason you can enter different data sets of the same driver in MZ SpeakerDesigner and switch between them.

The biggest problem in simulation accuracy are surround resonances and the cone break-up at higher frequencies. They interact with the baffle edges and yield sometimes results, that are really hard to predict. I'm still working on that...

The knee in the SPL simulation at 20-30 Hz is caused by rear side vents, as their distance to the microphone is greater than the distance of the driver on the front. This effect disappears with increasing microphone distance.

The maximum SPL of a driver is limited in the simulation by its linear excursion and continuous power handling capability. According to that, MZ SpeakerDesigner displays the save operating area (SOA) of a loudspeaker. Expect the real (short time or distorted) maximum SPL to be about 3 dB higher.

Links

MZ SpeakerDesigner

Last update: 1 October 2013